Updated 17 November 2026 · BrokerCue Editorial Team

comdirect - eine Marke der Commerzbank AG vs Moneyfarm

comdirect - eine Marke der Commerzbank AG

Best for: German investors comparing the described depot, app trading and transfer features.

Moneyfarm logo

Moneyfarm

9.1

Best for: Hands-off ISA and SIPP saving run on a percentage management fee.

See the category

Side by side

comdirect - eine Marke der Commerzbank AG vs Moneyfarm
comdirect - eine Marke der Commerzbank AGMoneyfarm logoMoneyfarm
Cost
Stock trade feeNot listed£3.95in the highest quarter of 15 brokers
Currency conversion feeNot listed0.7%in the highest quarter of 38 brokers
Deposit and withdrawal feesNot listedNo deposit or withdrawal fees
Trust
RegulatorsNot listedFinancial Conduct Authority
Investor protectionNot listedFSCS up to £85,000
Company
Legal entityCommerzbank AGMFM Investment Ltd
HeadquartersGermanyUnited Kingdom
Founded1994Not listed
Support channelsNot listedEmail, Phone, Help centre, Chat
Robo-advisors
Management feeNot listed0.1% to 0.45%
Offer
MarketsNot listedStocks, ETFs, Bonds, Funds
Account typesNot listedISA, SIPP
Robo-advisors
Minimum investmentNot listed£500
Portfolio typesETFETF, ESG, Cash, Crypto

Our verdict on each

comdirect - eine Marke der Commerzbank AG

Comdirect’s German securities depot supports trading through its app. The indexed depot-page excerpt describes online orders for foreign shares in 11 countries and a service for transferring securities from another bank. The excerpt does not confirm current origin status.

Read the full comdirect - eine Marke der Commerzbank AG review

Moneyfarm

Moneyfarm suits UK savers who want an ISA or SIPP built and run for them, and who are content paying a percentage fee rather than trading directly. The management fee of 0.1% to 0.45% is the figure to weigh, and it sits above the median for robo-advisors.

Read the full Moneyfarm review

How they place

Robo-advisors
comdirect - eine Marke der Commerzbank AG 104 of 145 by score · Moneyfarm 43 of 145 by score

Pros and cons

comdirect - eine Marke der Commerzbank AG

Pros

  • The depot information describes app-based trading and online foreign-share orders in 11 countries.
  • A depot-transfer service is listed for securities held at other banks.

Cons

Not listed

Moneyfarm

Pros

  • Regulated in the UK by the Financial Conduct Authority, with licence 629539 to check on the register.
  • Deposits and withdrawals carry no charge, so money can move in and out without a transaction fee eating the saving.
  • Portfolio styles run to ETF, ESG and cash, letting a saver tilt towards ESG, cash or crypto alongside a diversified core.

Cons

  • The account range is ISA and SIPP accounts, so money held outside a wrapper has no home here.

Who each suits

comdirect - eine Marke der Commerzbank AG

Who it suits

  • People in Germany comparing securities-depot features described for comdirect.

Who should look elsewhere

Not listed

Moneyfarm

Who it suits

  • UK savers who want an ISA or SIPP run for them and would rather pay a percentage than place their own trades.
  • People who want help by phone, chat and email as well as online, since support runs on email, phone and help centre.
  • Investors who want their portfolio style to include ESG, cash or crypto, since the options run to ETF, ESG and cash.

Who should look elsewhere

  • Anyone who prefers running their own trades: eToro lists a management fee of 0%, so the cost sits elsewhere.

Questions about each

Moneyfarm

What does Moneyfarm charge to run my money?

The ongoing cost is a management fee of 0.1% to 0.45% on the value of the portfolio, taken as a percentage of what you hold rather than as a price per trade. Accounts open at £500, so the fee applies to whatever sits above that floor.

Is there a fee for buying or selling?

A stock trade fee of £3.95 is listed for anyone who places a trade, and it sits alongside the management fee. Because the portfolio is run for you, the management fee is the line that does most of the work in practice.

Who regulates Moneyfarm in the UK?

The UK operation is regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority, with licence number 629539. Investor protection runs through the FSCS, and the provider states the ceiling that applies to eligible balances, so a claim is capped rather than open-ended.

What does it cost to deposit and withdraw?

Deposits and withdrawals carry no charge, so funding the account and taking money out adds no transaction cost. The opening payment still has to meet the £500 entry point, and the money you fund is held in ISA and SIPP accounts.