Updated · BrokerCue Editorial Team

How to choose a SIPP provider

Compare how a SIPP provider charges, what you can hold, how the account is run, listed regulators, protection scheme and support before you choose one.

What a SIPP provider is for

A self-invested personal pension, or SIPP, is a UK pension account where you choose the investments. The provider is the company that holds the pension and gives you a platform to buy and sell. The government sets the tax treatment, the yearly limits and the age from which you can take money, and these rules can change.

Investments can fall in value as well as rise, and pension money is tied up until the access age. This guide describes what to compare. It is not pension, tax or investment advice.

What decides the value of a provider

Charges come first, and they come in layers. A provider may charge an account fee, a management charge on ready-made portfolios, a dealing charge on each trade, a currency conversion charge on overseas investments and a fee when you transfer out or take money from the account. Over a long period these add up, so look at the whole structure for the way you would use the account.

Then look at what you can hold, how the platform works and how you reach support. Decide how much of the work you want to do. Some providers let you choose every holding, and others offer portfolios they manage for you.

How the providers differ

Charles Stanley Direct is a British provider founded in 1792. It lists stocks, ETFs and funds as markets, an ISA and a SIPP as account types, a trading platform under its own name, and support by email and phone. It names the Financial Conduct Authority as regulator and lists FSCS in its investor protection entry.

Plum is a British provider founded in 2016, run by Plum Fintech Limited. It works through a mobile app and lists an ISA, a SIPP and a lifetime ISA, with portfolio types built from ETFs and cash. It supports customers by email and a help centre. Dodl lists AJ Bell as its legal entity and works through its own app, with an ISA, a SIPP and a lifetime ISA, and support through email, chat and a help centre. Freetrade is a British provider founded in 2016 with an app and a web platform. It lists an ISA, a SIPP and a junior ISA, with support by email, chat and a help centre.

Platform, app or full service

Some SIPP providers focus on a simple mobile app with a limited menu of investments. Others offer a full platform with a wide range of funds, shares and ETFs, research tools and more control over what you hold. A simple app may suit a small, steady pension, while a fuller platform may suit someone who wants a wider choice.

Check whether you can see every charge in the app or on the platform, and whether you can switch between ready-made and self-chosen investments.

Regulators, protection and transfers

Look at the regulator the provider names and find its entry on the register. Check the legal entity that will hold your pension and the protection scheme the provider lists. A scheme such as the FSCS is designed for certain failures at a firm, and it does not cover falls in the value of your investments.

If you want to move an older pension into a SIPP, check what you may give up first. Some older pensions carry valuable benefits, and a transfer is hard to reverse. The provider you are leaving and official pension guidance can explain the terms.

What to check before you open an account

Look at how contributions are made and how tax relief is claimed, and how the provider handles employer contributions. Check how long a transfer in is expected to take, what the provider says about its charges for transfers out and how you can take money when you reach the access age.

Read the terms and the full charge schedule. Look at how support can be reached when something goes wrong with a transfer or a payment.

How to shortlist

List what you want to hold, how involved you want to be and whether you will transfer an existing pension, then keep the providers that offer a SIPP with those features and name a regulator you can find on a register. Compare the full charge schedule for the way you would use the account. The SIPP provider ranking lists the providers side by side.

See the full ranking: Top SIPP providers compared →

Sources