Updated 17 November 2026 · BrokerCue Editorial Team
Lightyear vs Smartbroker

Lightyear
No. 36 of 462 in stock and ETF brokers8.9Best for: Cost aware investors seeking varied markets with calm upkeep
Smartbroker
No. 58 of 462 in stock and ETF brokers9.4Best for: Anyone starting a European stock, ETF or crypto portfolio with no monthly charge.
Key differences
- Smartbroker scores higher overall: 9.4 against 8.9.
- Only Lightyear is regulated by Estonian Financial Supervision Authority and Estonian Financial Supervision Authority (EFSA).
- Only Smartbroker is regulated by Federal Financial Supervisory Authority (BaFin).
- Smartbroker has more markets (6 against 5).
- Among features, only Lightyear offers Fractional shares.
Side by side
Lightyear | ||
|---|---|---|
| Cost | ||
| Minimum deposit | Not listed | €0below the median of 44 brokers |
| Stock trade fee | $1in the highest quarter of 92 brokers | Not listed |
| Account fee | €0 / year | €0 / year |
| Inactivity fee | €0below the median of 14 brokers | Not listed |
| Currency conversion fee | 0.35%below the median of 38 brokers | Not listed |
| Deposit and withdrawal fees | No deposit or withdrawal fees | Not listed |
| Offer | ||
| Markets | Stocks, ETFs, Crypto, Bonds, Funds | Stocks, ETFs, Crypto, Bonds, Funds, MetalsMore |
| Platforms | Not listed | Web, App |
| Account types | Corporate | Not listed |
| Interest on cash | 2.42%Higher | 2.25% |
| Trust | ||
| Regulators | Estonian Financial Supervision Authority, Estonian Financial Supervision Authority (EFSA) | Federal Financial Supervisory Authority (BaFin) |
| Investor protection | EU ICS up to €20,000 | EU ICS up to €20,000 |
| Other facts | ||
| Features | Crypto, Fractional shares | Crypto, Mobile app |
| Pricing model | Low fees | Low fees |
| Company | ||
| Legal entity | Not listed | Smartbroker AG |
| Headquarters | Not listed | Germany |
| Support channels | Not listed | Email, Phone, Help centre |
Part scores
Lightyear
Our verdict on each
Lightyear
Lightyear suits you if you want stocks, ETFs, bonds, funds and crypto in a place with clear upkeep costs and email based help.
Read the full Lightyear reviewSmartbroker
Smartbroker runs a European brokerage with a €0 account fee and a €0 minimum deposit, which puts it at 1 on the site for deposit levels. It suits investors who want stocks, ETFs, funds and crypto in one account and would rather not pay a monthly charge.
Read the full Smartbroker reviewPros and cons
Lightyear
Pros
- Account upkeep at €0 and inactivity at €0 keep quiet months calm
- You can hold stocks, ETFs and crypto with fractional shares available for smaller positions
Cons
- Support runs on email and help centre only, so you use email and help centre without phone or chat
Smartbroker
Pros
- Nothing to pay to open.
- One account covers stocks, etfs and crypto.
Cons
- Support runs on email, phone and help centre only, with no live chat listed.
- Markets stop at stocks, etfs and crypto, with no forex, options or futures listed.
Who each suits
Lightyear
Who it suits
- You want upkeep at €0 and inactivity at €0 and prefer XTB only if ticket fees matter more
- You seek stocks, ETFs and crypto from modest sums starting at €1 rather than eToro style ranged pricing
Who should look elsewhere
- You trade stocks very often and want ticket fees of $0 from ActivTrades rather than fees of $1
- You want phone or chat help rather than help on email and help centre, so XTB may suit you better
Smartbroker
Who it suits
- European investors who want a German-regulated account holding stocks, etfs and crypto under one roof.
- People who trade away from a desk, since access runs through Web and App.
Who should look elsewhere
- eToro, if your trading runs past the stocks, etfs and crypto list here and you want to weigh its range against Smartbroker’s.
Questions about each
Lightyear
What will I pay to trade stocks and keep the account open?
Stock orders carry fees of $1. Account upkeep sits at €0 and inactivity stays at €0. Currency conversion applies at 0.35% when your trade currency differs from your account currency.
Who regulates Lightyear and where can I check it?
Lightyear names Estonian Financial Supervision Authority (EFSA) as its supervisors. Oversight sits in Estonia under MiCA CASP 254900BBBJZF2IE8EN54. You can check the licence details on the relevant public register before you fund an account.
Smartbroker
What does Smartbroker charge to hold an account?
The account fee is €0, so there is no monthly charge for keeping the account open. Entry is also open, with a minimum deposit of €0. Trading costs still apply on individual orders, and the pricing page is where per-trade charges are set out.
What can I trade on the platform?
The market list covers stocks, etfs and crypto, so equities, ETFs, funds, bonds, metals and crypto sit in the same account. Trading runs on Web and App, and a mobile app appears in the feature list. Forex, options and futures are not part of that range.







