Updated 28 September 2026 · BrokerCue Editorial Team

Firstrade vs Stash

Firstrade logo

Firstrade

No. 44 of 462 in stock and ETF brokers9.5

Best for: US retail investors wanting commission-free stock trading plus an IRA or joint account.

Stash logo

Stash

No. 149 of 462 in stock and ETF brokers9.0

Best for: Phone-first retirement saving for US beginners, priced by subscription rather than commission.

See the category

Key differences

  • Firstrade scores higher overall: 9.5 against 9.0.
  • Only Firstrade is regulated by SIPC.
  • Only Stash is regulated by SEC.
  • Firstrade has a lower account fee ($0 / year against $144 / year).
  • Firstrade has more markets (4 against 2).

Side by side

Firstrade vs Stash
Firstrade logoFirstradeStash logoStash
Cost
Minimum deposit$0$0
Stock trade fee$0$0
Account fee$0 / yearat the median of 52 brokers$144 / yearin the highest quarter of 52 brokers
Inactivity fee$0at the median of 37 brokersNot listed
Options contract fee$0in the lowest quarter of 38 brokersNot listed
Deposit and withdrawal feesFree for bank transfers, $25 for wire transfersNot listed
Offer
MarketsStocks, ETFs, Options, FundsMoreStocks, ETFs
PlatformsWeb, iOS, Android, IPadMoreWeb, iOS, Android
Account typesIRA, Roth IRA, JointMoreIRA, Roth IRA
Trust
RegulatorsSIPC, FINRASEC, FINRA
Investor protectionSIPC up to $500,000SIPC up to $500,000
Other facts
FeaturesDemo account, Options, Mobile app, Fractional sharesFractional shares, Mobile app
Pricing modelCommission freeCommission free
AudienceBeginners, Experienced, Day tradersBeginners
Company
Legal entityFIRSTRADE SECURITIES INCStash Investments LLC
HeadquartersUnited StatesUnited States
Founded19852015
Support channelsPhone, Help centreHelp centre

Part scores

Firstrade

  • CostThe price to start, as the brand lists it, set against the others in its category. Read more9.5
  • OfferWhat a new customer gets to begin with, and on what terms. Read more9.4
  • TrustCompany, licence and policy details we could check. Read more9.6

Stash

  • CostThe price to start, as the brand lists it, set against the others in its category. Read more9.1
  • OfferWhat a new customer gets to begin with, and on what terms. Read more8.8
  • TrustCompany, licence and policy details we could check. Read more9.0

Our verdict on each

Firstrade

Firstrade is a US commission-free broker for retail savers who want retirement accounts and low costs in the same place.

Read the full Firstrade review

Stash

Stash suits US beginners who want a retirement pot built from a phone rather than a wide market. Trades cost $0 and the minimum deposit is free, but the account fee of $144 a year is the price of that simplicity.

Read the full Stash review

How they place

Investment platforms and apps
Firstrade 13 of 91 by score · Stash 34 of 91 by score
Brokers for beginners
Firstrade 13 of 90 by score · Stash 40 of 90 by score
IRA providers
Firstrade 7 of 44 by score · Stash 22 of 44 by score

What it costs in practice

A year: 5,000 invested, 4 US stock trades a month

Firstrade

$0

48 × $0 + 1 × $0

Stash

$144

48 × $0 + 1 × $144

Firstrade costs $144 less.

Worked out from the stated prices and rates; your own total depends on how you use it. Facts checked 26 September 2026.

Pros and cons

Firstrade

Pros

  • A traditional IRA, a Roth IRA and a joint account all sit in IRA, roth IRA and joint under the commission-free pricing in commission free, so retirement and shared accounts hold at the same cost.
  • Fractional shares and a demo account sit in demo account, options and mobile app, which helps the beginners and day traders named in beginners, experienced and day traders start small.
  • Trading runs on the platforms in Web, iOS and Android, so the same account works in a browser and on a phone or tablet.

Cons

  • Live chat and email are not among the listed support channels, which pair a phone line with a help centre.
  • An ISA and a SIPP are not among the listed account types (IRA, roth IRA and joint), which cover a traditional IRA, a Roth IRA and a joint account.

Stash

Pros

  • Stock trades cost $0 and the model is commission-free, so small orders carry no per-trade charge.
  • The portfolio option is an ETF portfolio alongside IRA and roth IRA accounts, which keeps retirement saving in one place.
  • Access runs through Web, iOS and Android, and fractional shares spread small contributions across holdings.

Cons

  • Support runs on help centre only, so questions about a retirement account are left to articles.
  • Trading is limited to stocks and etfs with an ETF portfolio, so there is no forex, crypto or CFD route.

Who each suits

Firstrade

Who it suits

  • US savers who want commission-free stock and ETF trading inside a retirement account, since the list in IRA, roth IRA and joint covers an IRA and a Roth IRA.
  • Investors who trade in small amounts, because fractional shares in demo account, options and mobile app work alongside a $0 entry point.
  • Day traders in US equities, named in beginners, experienced and day traders with a mobile app among the platforms in Web, iOS and Android.

Who should look elsewhere

  • Traders who want forex, CFDs or crypto alongside equities: eToro lists stocks, etfs and forex and CFI lists stocks, etfs and forex, while Firstrade stays within stocks, etfs and options.
  • UK and European savers who need a tax wrapper, since IRA, roth IRA and joint names no ISA or SIPP. Vantage, which sets $5 as its entry point, is worth pricing alongside.

Stash

Who it suits

  • US beginners who want a retirement account, a phone app and a small starting amount rather than a wide market.
  • Long-term savers content to hold stocks and etfs and an ETF portfolio without picking markets themselves.
  • Readers who weigh regulation first, since Stash is registered with SEC and FINRA in the US.

Who should look elsewhere

  • Readers who want forex, crypto or CFDs, since CFI lists stocks, etfs and forex.
  • Anyone put off by a yearly charge, as eToro lists $0 for its account.
  • Readers who prefer a provider with a published entry figure, such as Vantage at $5, rather than a free minimum deposit.

Questions about each

Firstrade

What does it cost to trade stocks and options?

Stock trades cost $0 and the options contract fee is $0, so nothing is charged per trade on either side. The pricing model listed is commission free, which matches that, and the same terms apply to stocks and options contracts. A reader comparing quotes will find the same line on both markets.

Are there account or inactivity fees?

The account fee is $0 and the inactivity fee is $0, so an account can sit open and untouched without an annual charge or a dormant penalty. That suits a saver who funds a retirement account and does not trade every month, since holding a small balance costs nothing beyond the trades themselves.

Stash

How much does Stash cost to run?

Running the plan costs a management fee of $108 to $144 a year, and the account fee is $144. Stock trades cost $0 and the model is commission-free, so the charge sits with the subscription rather than the order.

How much do I need to start?

The minimum deposit is free, and the minimum investment is $5, so an account can be opened at a size that suits a monthly habit rather than a lump sum.

Sources

Firstrade

  • firstrade.com: 12 facts, checked 26 September 2026
  • brokerchooser.com: 3 facts, checked 26 September 2026
  • sipc.org: 3 facts, checked 26 September 2026

Stash

  • stash.com: 14 facts, checked 26 September 2026
  • tradingplatforms.com: 1 fact, checked 26 September 2026