Updated 14 October 2026 · BrokerCue Editorial Team
Davy Select vs Tradier
Davy Select
No. 206 of 462 in stock and ETF brokers8.6Best for: Irish investors comparing a self-directed, execution-only investment service and its stated risk limitations.
Tradier
No. 152 of 462 in stock and ETF brokers9.0Best for: Experienced US traders who want commission-free stock dealing and a wide market list.
Key differences
- Tradier scores higher overall: 9.0 against 8.6.
- Only Davy Select is regulated by Central Bank of Ireland.
- Among support channels, only Davy Select offers Phone.
Side by side
| Cost | ||
|---|---|---|
| Minimum deposit | Not listed | $500in the highest quarter of 136 brokers |
| Stock trade fee | Not listed | $0at the median of 92 brokers |
| Account fee | Not listed | $120 / yearin the highest quarter of 52 brokers |
| Inactivity fee | €50in the highest quarter of 14 brokers | Not listed |
| Currency conversion fee | 1%in the highest quarter of 38 brokers | Not listed |
| Options contract fee | Not listed | $0.35 |
| Deposit and withdrawal fees | Not listed | $30 per wire |
| Trust | ||
| Regulators | Central Bank of Ireland | FINRA, SIPC |
| Investor protection | EU ICS up to €20,000 | SIPC up to $500,000 |
| Company | ||
| Legal entity | J & E Davy Unlimited Company | TRADIER BROKERAGE INC |
| Headquarters | Not listed | United States |
| Founded | Not listed | 2012 |
| Support channels | Email, Phone, Help centre | Email, Help centre |
| Cost | ||
| Margin rate | Not listed | 9.75%above the median of 23 brokers |
| Offer | ||
| Markets | Not listed | Stocks, Options, Futures, Crypto, Forex, ETFs |
| Platforms | Not listed | Tradier Pro, Tradier Web, Tradier Mobile |
| Account types | Joint, Corporate | Not listed |
| Other facts | ||
| Features | Not listed | Crypto, Futures, Options, Mobile app |
| Pricing model | Not listed | Commission free |
| Audience | Not listed | Experienced, Day traders |
Part scores
Davy Select
Our verdict on each
Davy Select
Davy Select describes an Irish execution-only service for investors who make their own decisions without financial advice. The provider warns that investments can lose value.
Read the full Davy Select reviewTradier
Tradier is a US broker for experienced traders and day traders who want commission-free stock dealing across stocks, options, futures, crypto, forex and ETFs. Stock trades cost $0 and the account fee is $120, though a minimum deposit of $500 puts a floor.
Read the full Tradier reviewPros and cons
Davy Select
Pros
- Davy Select clearly describes execution-only investing without financial advice.
Cons
- Investments can lose value, and the service does not provide financial advice in this execution-only model.
Tradier
Pros
- Stock trades are commission-free at $0
- Deals in stocks, options and futures from one account
- Accounts run on Tradier Pro, Tradier Web and Tradier Mobile
Cons
- The account fee of $120 applies where most rivals charge nothing
- Funding and withdrawals cost $30 per wire
- Support runs on email and help centre only, with no phone or live chat line
Who each suits
Davy Select
Who it suits
- Investors comfortable making their own investment decisions and evaluating the risk that investments can lose value.
Who should look elsewhere
Not listed
Tradier
Who it suits
- Experienced traders who place regular stock, options and futures orders
- Day traders working across several markets at once
- US residents who want a regulated broker with SIPC cover
Who should look elsewhere
- eToro, if a free account fee matters more than a US-only setup
- CFI, if you want to start funding with a smaller minimum deposit
- Vantage, if a lower minimum deposit is the priority
Questions about each
Davy Select
Does execution-only include financial advice?
Davy Select describes the service as execution-only, where customers make their own investment decisions without financial advice.
Tradier
What does Tradier charge for buying stocks?
Stock trades are commission-free, with a stock trade fee of $0. The account fee of $120 still applies, and options contracts cost $0.35 each. Many rivals keep the account fee at $0, so weigh that against your trade volume.
Is there an account fee at Tradier?
Yes. The account fee is $120, which ranks the broker near the back of the field on this measure. If you would rather pay nothing on an idle account, eToro lists an account fee of $0.
How much do I need to deposit to open an account?
The minimum deposit is $500. That sits well above the $0 at CFI and the $5 at Vantage, so Tradier suits readers with a larger starting balance rather than a small first deposit.

