Updated 14 October 2026 · BrokerCue Editorial Team

Davy Select vs Tastytrade

Davy Select logo

Davy Select

No. 206 of 462 in stock and ETF brokers8.6

Best for: Irish investors comparing a self-directed, execution-only investment service and its stated risk limitations.

tastytrade logo

Tastytrade

No. 151 of 462 in stock and ETF brokers9.0

Best for: Traders building a share portfolio who also want options, futures and crypto in a single place.

See the category

Key differences

  • Tastytrade scores higher overall: 9.0 against 8.6.
  • Only Davy Select is regulated by Central Bank of Ireland.
  • Only Tastytrade is regulated by SIPC.
  • Among account types, only Davy Select offers Corporate.
  • Among account types, only Tastytrade offers IRA.

Side by side

Davy Select vs Tastytrade
Davy Select logoDavy Selecttastytrade logoTastytrade
Cost
Minimum depositNot listed$0below the median of 136 brokers
Stock trade feeNot listed$0at the median of 92 brokers
Inactivity fee€50in the highest quarter of 14 brokersNot listed
Currency conversion fee1%in the highest quarter of 38 brokersNot listed
Options contract feeNot listed$1in the highest quarter of 38 brokers
Trust
RegulatorsCentral Bank of IrelandSIPC
Investor protectionEU ICS up to €20,000SIPC up to $500,000
Company
Legal entityJ & E Davy Unlimited CompanyTASTYTRADE INC
Support channelsEmail, Phone, Help centreNot listed
Offer
MarketsNot listedStocks, ETFs, Forex, Options, Futures, Crypto
PlatformsNot listedMobile, Desktop, Web
Account typesJoint, CorporateIRA, Joint
Other facts
FeaturesNot listedCrypto, Mobile app
Pricing modelNot listedCommission free

Part scores

Davy Select

  • CostThe price to start, as the brand lists it, set against the others in its category. Read more8.0
  • OfferWhat a new customer gets to begin with, and on what terms. Read more9.3
  • TrustCompany, licence and policy details we could check. Read more8.6

Tastytrade

  • CostThe price to start, as the brand lists it, set against the others in its category. Read more9.1
  • OfferWhat a new customer gets to begin with, and on what terms. Read more9.4
  • TrustCompany, licence and policy details we could check. Read more8.6

Our verdict on each

Davy Select

Davy Select describes an Irish execution-only service for investors who make their own decisions without financial advice. The provider warns that investments can lose value.

Read the full Davy Select review

Tastytrade

Tastytrade suits traders who want options, futures and crypto in the same account as shares and ETFs, and it suits anyone starting small. The minimum deposit is $0, share dealing costs $0 a trade, and options cost $1 a contract, so the bill grows only if you trade derivatives.

Read the full Tastytrade review

How they place

Investment platforms and apps
Davy Select 49 of 91 by score · Tastytrade 35 of 91 by score

Pros and cons

Davy Select

Pros

  • Davy Select clearly describes execution-only investing without financial advice.

Cons

  • Investments can lose value, and the service does not provide financial advice in this execution-only model.

Tastytrade

Pros

  • Share dealing costs $0 a trade, and the account opens from $0.
  • All of stocks, etfs and forex sit under the same account.
  • Platforms cover Mobile, Desktop and Web, so a phone and a desk show the same account.

Cons

  • Options cost $1 a contract, so regular contract buyers pay more than occasional ones.
  • The recorded account types under IRA and joint are an IRA and a joint account.

Who each suits

Davy Select

Who it suits

  • Investors comfortable making their own investment decisions and evaluating the risk that investments can lose value.

Who should look elsewhere

Not listed

Tastytrade

Who it suits

  • Traders who want options and futures in the same account as shares and ETFs.
  • Anyone starting small, since the minimum deposit is $0.
  • People saving into an IRA who also want crypto and forex nearby.

Who should look elsewhere

  • eToro if you want CFDs listed alongside the core markets: stocks, etfs and forex.
  • CFI if you want the shorter list in stocks, etfs and forex, which ends at crypto.

Questions about each

Davy Select

Does execution-only include financial advice?

Davy Select describes the service as execution-only, where customers make their own investment decisions without financial advice.

Tastytrade

Is there a minimum deposit to open a tastytrade account?

The minimum deposit is $0, so an account can be opened and funded with whatever you want to start on. Share dealing then costs $0 a trade, which keeps the running cost close to the opening balance.

What does an options contract cost?

Options are charged per contract at $1. If you buy options often, that fee becomes the main line you track, while share dealing stays at $0. Traders who touch options now and then will feel it far less than regular contract buyers.

Which markets can I trade on tastytrade?

The market list runs to stocks, ETFs, forex, options, futures and crypto, etfs and forex, so derivatives trades sit alongside shares in a single account. Moving from shares into options or futures stays in that same account.