Updated 17 November 2026 · BrokerCue Editorial Team

CI Direct Investing vs ModernAdvisor

CI Direct Investing logo

CI Direct Investing

No. 72 of 145 in robo-advisors8.8

Best for: A managed ETF and ESG portfolio from a small deposit, run on a phone.

ModernAdvisor logo

ModernAdvisor

No. 65 of 145 in robo-advisors8.9

Best for: Canadian savers who want one managed ETF portfolio run for them with a single ongoing fee.

See the category

Key differences

  • ModernAdvisor scores higher overall: 8.9 against 8.8.
  • ModernAdvisor has a lower management fee (0.2% to 0.9% against 0.35% to 0.6%).
  • Among portfolio types, only ModernAdvisor offers Cash.
  • Among support channels, only ModernAdvisor offers Phone.

Side by side

CI Direct Investing vs ModernAdvisor
CI Direct Investing logoCI Direct InvestingModernAdvisor logoModernAdvisor
Cost
Management fee0.35% to 0.6%above the median of 85 brokers0.2% to 0.9%Lowerbelow the median of 85 brokers
Minimum investmentCA$100Lowerin the lowest quarter of 6 brokersCA$1,000 to CA$5,000above the median of 6 brokers
Portfolio typesETF, ESGETF, ESG, Cash
RegulatorsNot listedProvincial securities commissions (registered portfolio manager in all Canadian provinces)
Company
Legal entityCI Investment Services Inc.Modern Advisor Canada Inc.
HeadquartersCanadaCanada
Support channelsEmail, Help centreEmail, Phone, Help centre
Brokers
Minimum depositCA$100Not listed
Deposit and withdrawal feesNo deposit or withdrawal feesNot listed
Brokers
MarketsStocks, ETFsMoreETFs
FeaturesMobile appNot listed
Pricing modelLow feesNot listed
PlatformsMobile appNot listed

Our verdict on each

CI Direct Investing

CI Direct Investing suits investors in Canada who want a managed portfolio of ETFs and ESG funds rather than picking shares themselves, since the minimum investment is CAD 100. Deposits and withdrawals are free deposits and withdrawals, and the whole account runs on mobile app.

Read the full CI Direct Investing review

ModernAdvisor

Modern Advisor is a Canadian automated adviser for savers who want a managed ETF portfolio handled for them, not a place to trade. Costs suit steady monthly investors, but a 0.2% to 0.9% management fee and a CAD 1,000 to CAD 5,000 minimum ask for a real pot before you start.

Read the full ModernAdvisor review

How they place

Stock and ETF brokers
CI Direct Investing 176 of 462 by score · ModernAdvisor 166 of 462 by score

Pros and cons

CI Direct Investing

Pros

  • Free deposits and withdrawals, so moving money in and out adds nothing to what you invest.
  • A low fees model, so the annual charge does not rise when you trade more often.

Cons

  • Support runs on email and help centre only, so a question goes by email or into the help centre rather than to a person on the phone.
  • Mobile app is the only platform, so managing the account means working on a phone.
  • Investing covers stocks and etfs, and the managed portfolios come in ETF and ESG varieties only.

ModernAdvisor

Pros

  • Registered as a portfolio manager with the provincial securities commissions in all Canadian provinces
  • Portfolio choice covers ETF, ESG and cash options, so risk can be adjusted over time
  • Help is available by email, phone and help centre

Cons

  • Shares are not among its markets, which cover etfs

Who each suits

CI Direct Investing

Who it suits

  • Investors in Canada who want a managed basket of ETF and ESG portfolios rather than choosing shares themselves.
  • New investors who can begin with CAD 100 and grow the account as income allows.
  • People who do their investing on mobile app and prefer a low fees pricing model to per-trade costs.

Who should look elsewhere

  • Investors who will not pay an annual management fee, since eToro charges 0%.

ModernAdvisor

Who it suits

  • Canadian residents with a lump sum who would rather not choose investments themselves
  • Investors who want ESG or cash portfolios alongside the core ETF option
  • People who prefer one ongoing charge to per-trade commissions

Who should look elsewhere

  • Anyone wanting to trade shares, as Modern Advisor covers ETFs only
  • Small investors building a portfolio slowly, held back by the CAD 1,000 to CAD 5,000 minimum
  • Readers in the UK and Europe, since the minimum is set in Canadian dollars and the firm is registered as a portfolio manager in all Canadian provinces

Questions about each

CI Direct Investing

How much does CI Direct Investing cost?

The management fee runs 0.35% to 0.6% a year on the portfolio, and it is a low fees setup rather than a per-trade charge. eToro, for comparison, charges 0% in management fees, so the trade-off is an annual cost in exchange for not choosing shares.

What do I need to start an account?

Deposits start at CAD 100, and the minimum investment across the managed portfolios is CAD 100, so a small amount is enough to hold a portfolio. Because the model is low fees, the annual charge applies to what you hold rather than to each transaction.

ModernAdvisor

What does Modern Advisor charge to manage my money?

Modern Advisor charges a management fee of 0.2% to 0.9%, taken as a set ongoing rate rather than a commission per trade. Robo-advisors across the comparison table charge a median of 0.35%, so read the two against each other before you commit.

How much do I need to start investing?

The minimum investment is CAD 1,000 to CAD 5,000.