Updated 28 September 2026 · BrokerCue Editorial Team
ChoiceTrade vs Nutmeg

ChoiceTrade
No. 157 of 462 in stock and ETF brokers8.9Best for: Experienced US traders wanting commission-free stocks, ETFs and options on a SIPC protected account.

Nutmeg
No. 101 of 462 in stock and ETF brokers9.2Best for: A managed ISA or SIPP portfolio for UK investors who do not want to choose their own funds.
Key differences
- Nutmeg scores higher overall: 9.2 against 8.9.
- Only ChoiceTrade is regulated by SIPC.
- Only Nutmeg is regulated by Financial Conduct Authority.
- Among markets, only ChoiceTrade offers Options.
- Among markets, only Nutmeg offers Funds and Bonds.
Side by side
ChoiceTrade | Nutmeg | |
|---|---|---|
| Cost | ||
| Minimum deposit | $100 | £500 |
| Stock trade fee | $0 | £0 |
| Account fee | $10 / yearabove the median of 52 brokers | Not listed |
| Options contract fee | $0.40below the median of 38 brokers | Not listed |
| Deposit and withdrawal fees | Not listed | no set-up, trading or exit fees |
| Offer | ||
| Markets | Stocks, ETFs, Options | ETFs, Funds, Stocks, Bonds |
| Platforms | ChoiceTrade Direct Pro, ChoiceTrade Elite, Mobile Apps | Web, Mobile app |
| Account types | Not listed | ISA, SIPP |
| Trust | ||
| Regulators | SIPC | Financial Conduct Authority |
| Investor protection | SIPC up to $500,000 | FSCS up to £85,000 |
| Other facts | ||
| Features | Demo account, Mobile app | Mobile app |
| Pricing model | Commission free | Commission free |
| Audience | Experienced | Not listed |
| Company | ||
| Legal entity | LETSGOTRADE INC | J.P. Morgan Personal Investing Limited |
| Headquarters | United States | United Kingdom |
| Founded | 2000 | 2012 |
| Support channels | Email, Phone | Email, Chat, Phone, Help centre |
Part scores
ChoiceTrade
Our verdict on each
ChoiceTrade
ChoiceTrade runs commission-free stock and ETF dealing, with an account fee of $10 and a minimum deposit of $100. It suits experienced US traders who want a long-standing, SIPC protected broker and do not mind paying to hold the account. Options cost $0.40 per contract.
Read the full ChoiceTrade reviewNutmeg
Nutmeg suits UK investors who want a managed portfolio held in an ISA or SIPP rather than a self-directed dealing account.
Read the full Nutmeg reviewPros and cons
ChoiceTrade
Pros
- Stock trades carry a fee of $0 and rank first among 161 brands on that measure
- Trading platforms include ChoiceTrade Direct Pro, ChoiceTrade Elite and Mobile Apps, so orders can go from desktop to phone
- Support runs on email and phone and a demo account is available for practice
Cons
- The audience is listed as experienced traders, so a first account may feel technical
Nutmeg
Pros
- Holdings span etfs, funds and stocks, so a managed basket can still cover a wide spread of asset types.
- The same portfolios can sit in an ISA or a SIPP (ISA and SIPP), so the wrapper does not change the investments.
- Support runs through email, chat and phone, which includes a phone line as well as chat, email and a help centre.
Cons
- The portfolio range is ETF, ESG and cash only, so there is no crypto or thematic option to tilt towards.
- The account list is ISA and SIPP, so there is no general investment account or joint holding outside a wrapper.
Who each suits
ChoiceTrade
Who it suits
- Experienced traders who want commission-free stock and ETF dealing on a US account
- Investors who value SIPC protection and a long operating history
- Anyone who wants demo practice before committing real money
Who should look elsewhere
- eToro, which charges an account fee of $0
- CFI, which takes a minimum deposit of $0
- Vantage, whose minimum deposit is $5
Nutmeg
Who it suits
- UK investors who want a managed portfolio inside an ISA or a SIPP and accept a single ongoing charge for the service.
- People who would rather not research individual funds, since the holdings run to ETF, ESG and cash approaches chosen and held for you.
- Investors who want a phone line as well as written support, since email, chat and phone includes phone, chat, email and a help centre.
Who should look elsewhere
Not listed
Questions about each
ChoiceTrade
What does it cost to trade stocks at ChoiceTrade?
Stock dealing is commission free, with a trade fee of $0. That is the measure on which the brand ranks 1 of 161, so trading itself adds nothing to the cost of a position.
Is there an account fee or minimum deposit?
Yes. The account fee is $10 and the minimum deposit is $100. On account fee the brand ranks 114 of 138, so this is where it costs more than cheaper rivals.
Nutmeg
What does Nutmeg charge to manage my money?
The charge is a single management fee of 0.25% to 0.75%, which sits above the robo-adviser median of 0.35% in this group. Money can go in from £100 to £500, so the cost is a percentage of what you hold rather than a price per deal.
How much do I need to open an account?
The minimum deposit is £500, and once the account is open money can go in from £100 to £500.







