Updated 28 September 2026 · BrokerCue Editorial Team

ChoiceTrade vs Nutmeg

ChoiceTrade logo

ChoiceTrade

No. 157 of 462 in stock and ETF brokers8.9

Best for: Experienced US traders wanting commission-free stocks, ETFs and options on a SIPC protected account.

Nutmeg logo

Nutmeg

No. 101 of 462 in stock and ETF brokers9.2

Best for: A managed ISA or SIPP portfolio for UK investors who do not want to choose their own funds.

See the category

Key differences

  • Nutmeg scores higher overall: 9.2 against 8.9.
  • Only ChoiceTrade is regulated by SIPC.
  • Only Nutmeg is regulated by Financial Conduct Authority.
  • Among markets, only ChoiceTrade offers Options.
  • Among markets, only Nutmeg offers Funds and Bonds.

Side by side

ChoiceTrade vs Nutmeg
ChoiceTrade logoChoiceTradeNutmeg logoNutmeg
Cost
Minimum deposit$100£500
Stock trade fee$0£0
Account fee$10 / yearabove the median of 52 brokersNot listed
Options contract fee$0.40below the median of 38 brokersNot listed
Deposit and withdrawal feesNot listedno set-up, trading or exit fees
Offer
MarketsStocks, ETFs, OptionsETFs, Funds, Stocks, Bonds
PlatformsChoiceTrade Direct Pro, ChoiceTrade Elite, Mobile AppsWeb, Mobile app
Account typesNot listedISA, SIPP
Trust
RegulatorsSIPCFinancial Conduct Authority
Investor protectionSIPC up to $500,000FSCS up to £85,000
Other facts
FeaturesDemo account, Mobile appMobile app
Pricing modelCommission freeCommission free
AudienceExperiencedNot listed
Company
Legal entityLETSGOTRADE INCJ.P. Morgan Personal Investing Limited
HeadquartersUnited StatesUnited Kingdom
Founded20002012
Support channelsEmail, PhoneEmail, Chat, Phone, Help centre

Part scores

ChoiceTrade

  • CostThe price to start, as the brand lists it, set against the others in its category. Read more8.9
  • OfferWhat a new customer gets to begin with, and on what terms. Read more9.0
  • TrustCompany, licence and policy details we could check. Read more8.9

Nutmeg

  • CostThe price to start, as the brand lists it, set against the others in its category. Read more9.0
  • OfferWhat a new customer gets to begin with, and on what terms. Read more9.6
  • TrustCompany, licence and policy details we could check. Read more9.1

Our verdict on each

ChoiceTrade

ChoiceTrade runs commission-free stock and ETF dealing, with an account fee of $10 and a minimum deposit of $100. It suits experienced US traders who want a long-standing, SIPC protected broker and do not mind paying to hold the account. Options cost $0.40 per contract.

Read the full ChoiceTrade review

Nutmeg

Nutmeg suits UK investors who want a managed portfolio held in an ISA or SIPP rather than a self-directed dealing account.

Read the full Nutmeg review

Pros and cons

ChoiceTrade

Pros

  • Stock trades carry a fee of $0 and rank first among 161 brands on that measure
  • Trading platforms include ChoiceTrade Direct Pro, ChoiceTrade Elite and Mobile Apps, so orders can go from desktop to phone
  • Support runs on email and phone and a demo account is available for practice

Cons

  • The audience is listed as experienced traders, so a first account may feel technical

Nutmeg

Pros

  • Holdings span etfs, funds and stocks, so a managed basket can still cover a wide spread of asset types.
  • The same portfolios can sit in an ISA or a SIPP (ISA and SIPP), so the wrapper does not change the investments.
  • Support runs through email, chat and phone, which includes a phone line as well as chat, email and a help centre.

Cons

  • The portfolio range is ETF, ESG and cash only, so there is no crypto or thematic option to tilt towards.
  • The account list is ISA and SIPP, so there is no general investment account or joint holding outside a wrapper.

Who each suits

ChoiceTrade

Who it suits

  • Experienced traders who want commission-free stock and ETF dealing on a US account
  • Investors who value SIPC protection and a long operating history
  • Anyone who wants demo practice before committing real money

Who should look elsewhere

  • eToro, which charges an account fee of $0
  • CFI, which takes a minimum deposit of $0
  • Vantage, whose minimum deposit is $5

Nutmeg

Who it suits

  • UK investors who want a managed portfolio inside an ISA or a SIPP and accept a single ongoing charge for the service.
  • People who would rather not research individual funds, since the holdings run to ETF, ESG and cash approaches chosen and held for you.
  • Investors who want a phone line as well as written support, since email, chat and phone includes phone, chat, email and a help centre.

Who should look elsewhere

Not listed

Questions about each

ChoiceTrade

What does it cost to trade stocks at ChoiceTrade?

Stock dealing is commission free, with a trade fee of $0. That is the measure on which the brand ranks 1 of 161, so trading itself adds nothing to the cost of a position.

Is there an account fee or minimum deposit?

Yes. The account fee is $10 and the minimum deposit is $100. On account fee the brand ranks 114 of 138, so this is where it costs more than cheaper rivals.

Nutmeg

What does Nutmeg charge to manage my money?

The charge is a single management fee of 0.25% to 0.75%, which sits above the robo-adviser median of 0.35% in this group. Money can go in from £100 to £500, so the cost is a percentage of what you hold rather than a price per deal.

How much do I need to open an account?

The minimum deposit is £500, and once the account is open money can go in from £100 to £500.