Updated 21 October 2026 · BrokerCue Editorial Team

Ally Bank vs comdirect - eine Marke der Commerzbank AG

Ally Bank logo

Ally Bank

9.6

Best for: Commission-free US share dealing with a free account and a free inactivity charge.

comdirect - eine Marke der Commerzbank AG

Best for: German investors comparing the described depot, app trading and transfer features.

See the category

Side by side

Ally Bank vs comdirect - eine Marke der Commerzbank AG
Ally Bank logoAlly Bankcomdirect - eine Marke der Commerzbank AG
Cost
Minimum deposit$0below the median of 136 brokersNot listed
Stock trade fee$0at the median of 92 brokersNot listed
Account fee$0 / yearat the median of 52 brokersNot listed
Inactivity fee$0at the median of 37 brokersNot listed
Options contract fee$0.50below the median of 38 brokersNot listed
Trust
RegulatorsSEC, FINRA, FDICNot listed
Investor protectionSIPC up to $500,000Not listed
Company
Legal entityAlly BankCommerzbank AG
HeadquartersUnited StatesGermany
Founded19191994
Support channelsEmail, Chat, Phone, Help centreNot listed
Robo-advisors
Management feeup to 0.3%Not listed
Offer
MarketsStocks, ETFs, Options, Funds, BondsNot listed
Account typesJoint, IRA, Roth IRANot listed
Trust
Pricing modelCommission freeNot listed
Robo-advisors
Minimum investment$100Not listed
Portfolio typesETF, ESG, CashETF

Our verdict on each

Ally Bank

Ally Bank suits US investors who want commission-free share dealing with a free account and a free inactivity charge, and it heads the cost table on the measures compared. The trade-off sits in the automated portfolios, which take a management fee of 0% to 0.3% and a starting investment of $100.

Read the full Ally Bank review

comdirect - eine Marke der Commerzbank AG

Comdirect’s German securities depot supports trading through its app. The indexed depot-page excerpt describes online orders for foreign shares in 11 countries and a service for transferring securities from another bank. The excerpt does not confirm current origin status.

Read the full comdirect - eine Marke der Commerzbank AG review

How they place

Robo-advisors
Ally Bank 8 of 145 by score · comdirect - eine Marke der Commerzbank AG 104 of 145 by score

Pros and cons

Ally Bank

Pros

  • A stock trade costs $0 and the account fee is $0, so holding a US portfolio costs nothing at the platform level.
  • The inactivity fee is $0, and Ally ranks 1 on that measure among 56, so a dormant balance is not quietly drained.
  • A bank behind the brokerage: the legal entity is Ally Bank, founded in 1919, so the deposit side carries the same name.

Cons

  • Options carry $0.50 per contract, so the commission-free model in commission free does not reach derivative trading.
  • Account types run to joint, IRA and roth IRA, with no wrapper for a tax-sheltered investor who is not saving through a retirement account.

comdirect - eine Marke der Commerzbank AG

Pros

  • The depot information describes app-based trading and online foreign-share orders in 11 countries.
  • A depot-transfer service is listed for securities held at other banks.

Cons

Not listed

Who each suits

Ally Bank

Who it suits

  • US savers who want commission-free share dealing, a minimum deposit of $0 and an account fee of $0.
  • Retirement investors, since joint, IRA and roth IRA covers individual retirement accounts and joint accounts.
  • People who would rather ring than email, since email, chat and phone includes phone, chat, email and a help centre.

Who should look elsewhere

  • Traders after forex, contracts for difference or crypto, since stocks, etfs and options stops at the US list while stocks, etfs and forex goes further.
  • Anyone who wants leveraged index exposure on the same account, where CFI covers stocks, etfs and forex and Ally does not.

comdirect - eine Marke der Commerzbank AG

Who it suits

  • People in Germany comparing securities-depot features described for comdirect.

Who should look elsewhere

Not listed

Questions about each

Ally Bank

What does it cost to open a self-directed account and place a trade?

Opening costs nothing beyond the deposit itself, and the minimum deposit is $0. Trading shares carries a fee of $0 and the account fee is $0, so a small starter order does not eat into the position. Options are the exception and are priced separately per contract.

Is there a charge if I leave the account empty?

No. The inactivity fee is $0, which means an account you stop using carries no monthly drain on the balance. It matters most for anyone splitting cash between trading and holding, because a dormant account here does not quietly shave the value of what sits in it while a decision is pending.

How much do options trades cost?

Each options contract carries $0.50. That sits on top of the commission-free dealing described in the model listed as commission free, so a share trade costs $0 while a derivative position does not. Anyone running a regular options strategy should treat the per-contract charge as the main ongoing cost rather than a rounding item.

Who regulates Ally and what protects my money?

Ally is regulated in the US by SEC, FINRA and FDIC, under a FINRA licence numbered 136131 and an FDIC certificate FDIC cert 57803. The account is held by Ally Bank, a bank entity, which is worth knowing before cash is transferred in.