What a bullion dealer is for
A bullion dealer sells gold, silver and other precious metals as bars and coins, and some also buy them back. You may take delivery at home, store the metal in a vault or hold a share of metal kept for you. Metals pay no income, and their price can fall as well as rise. This guide describes what to compare. It does not say whether to buy metal or how much.
Dealers differ in what they sell, how they price it, and what you hold at the end, so the details matter more than the brand name.
What decides the value of a dealer
Start with the price you pay compared with the market price of the metal. Dealers add a premium for making, handling and profit, and the premium differs by product, size and dealer. Small bars and coins often carry a higher premium per ounce than large bars. Add delivery, insurance and any storage charge to see the full cost.
Then look at what happens when you sell. A dealer sets its own price to buy metal back, and the gap between its buy and sell prices is part of what you pay. Check whether the dealer buys back at all, and how it describes the terms.
How the dealers differ
Kitco is a Canadian business founded in 1977, run through Kitco Metals Inc. It lists metals as its market and offers a mobile app. SD Bullion is a US dealer founded in 2012, run through SD Bullion, Inc. It lists metals as its market and supports customers by phone and a help centre.
Godot & Fils is a French dealer founded in 1933. It lists metals as its market and supports customers by phone and email. Glint works through its own app, and its legal entity is a Glint Pay company. It lists metals as its market, names the Financial Conduct Authority as regulator and lists FSCS in its investor protection entry, with support through a help centre. Read what the scheme covers before you rely on it for metal holdings.
Physical delivery, storage or a share of metal
Owning physical metal means you hold bars or coins yourself or have them stored for you. At home you carry the risk of loss and theft, and you may need insurance. In a vault you pay for storage and rely on the operator, so look at who holds the metal, whether it is allocated to you by serial number and whether you can inspect or collect it.
Some apps let you hold a share of a pool of metal that the provider keeps. That is a different product from owning bars, so check whether you own the metal itself or a claim on the provider, and what happens if the provider fails.
Authenticity, hallmarks and entity checks
Buy products that carry recognised marks of purity and weight, and check that the dealer’s description matches. Look for the dealer’s legal entity, how long it has been trading and what it says about the source of its metal. Be cautious about offers that look far away from the market price, and about dealers that push you to act quickly.
Where a dealer lists a regulator, look up the entity on that regulator’s register. Many bullion dealers are not supervised as investment firms, and a regulator name is a fact about the firm, not a view on the quality of its metal.
What to check before you buy
Read the delivery terms: how the parcel is packed, who insures it in transit, whether a signature is needed and what happens if it does not arrive. Check how long payment takes to clear, which payment methods are accepted and whether any method carries a surcharge. Look at the returns terms, since metal bought in error is often hard to send back.
Check how to reach support when an order goes wrong, and keep your invoices. Tax rules on metal differ by country and by product, so check the rules where you live.
How to shortlist
Decide whether you want physical bars or coins, storage or a share of metal, and which metals you want. Keep the dealers that serve your country and publish clear terms on pricing, delivery and buy-back. Compare the full cost of the same product from each dealer, including delivery. The precious metals dealer ranking lists the dealers side by side.