Updated · BrokerCue Editorial Team

How to choose a lifetime ISA provider

Compare which accounts a provider offers, what you can hold, how charges and withdrawals work, listed regulators, protection scheme and support.

What a lifetime ISA is for

A lifetime ISA is a UK account, designed for adults saving towards a first home or for later life. The government sets who can open one, the yearly allowance, the government payment added to contributions and the purposes for which money can be taken out without a charge. Taking money out for other reasons can bring a withdrawal charge. These rules can change, so check the official guidance.

Investments held in the account can fall in value as well as rise. This guide describes what to compare. It is not investment or tax advice, and it does not say whether a lifetime ISA suits you.

What decides the value of a provider

First check that the provider offers a lifetime ISA at all, since not every ISA provider does. Then look at what the account can hold. Some providers offer cash, others offer stocks, ETFs and funds, and some offer ready-made portfolios.

Charges come next: account fees, management charges, dealing charges and any charge when you transfer out. Look at how the provider treats withdrawals that do not meet the account’s rules, and whether it tells you before it processes one. Then check the platform, support channels and the regulator and protection scheme the provider lists.

How the providers differ

Hargreaves Lansdown was founded in 1981. It lists stocks, ETFs, funds and bonds as markets, a lifetime ISA among its account types alongside an ISA, a junior ISA and a SIPP, and support by phone and email. OneFamily lists a lifetime ISA and a junior ISA, with stocks and funds as markets. Its legal entity is a friendly society. It names the Financial Conduct Authority as regulator, lists FSCS in its investor protection entry and supports customers by help centre and email.

AJ Bell is a British provider that lists an ISA, a SIPP, a lifetime ISA and a junior ISA. It works through a web platform and a mobile app, names the Financial Conduct Authority as regulator and supports customers by chat and a help centre. J.P. Morgan Personal Investing lists the same four account types, with ETFs, funds and bonds as markets, a web platform and a mobile app. Its listing points to beginners and it supports customers through a help centre.

Account types, funds and cash

A lifetime ISA can be held in cash or in investments, depending on the provider. Cash carries no investment risk but may not keep up with prices over time. Investments can grow or shrink and may need years to recover from a fall. Providers differ in whether they offer the account as cash only, as investments only or as either.

If you plan to use the account for a first home, think about when you will need the money. A short time horizon and a volatile investment are a difficult mix, and the provider’s own pages explain how the account handles each use.

Regulators, protection and the legal entity

Look up the legal entity that will hold the account and find its entry on the register of the regulator the provider names. A friendly society, a bank group and an investment platform are different kinds of company, and each is supervised differently.

A protection scheme such as the FSCS is designed for certain failures at a firm. It does not cover falls in the value of investments, and the cover depends on the type of account and the entity, so read the scheme’s own description.

What to check before you open an account

Check how you can pay in, how transfers from another lifetime ISA are handled and whether any charge applies. Look at how withdrawals work and what happens if you take money out for a reason the rules do not allow. Check how the provider treats a change of address or a move abroad, and how it will reach you with changes to its terms.

Read the full charge schedule and the terms, and look at how support can be reached when something goes wrong.

How to shortlist

Write down what you want the account for, when you may need the money and whether you want cash or investments. Keep the providers that offer a lifetime ISA with those features and name a regulator you can find on a register. Compare the full charge schedule for the way you would use the account. The lifetime ISA provider ranking lists the providers side by side.

See the full ranking: Top lifetime ISA providers compared →

Sources