Updated · BrokerCue Editorial Team

How to choose an IRA provider

Compare account types, what you can hold, how charges are built, listed regulators, protection scheme and support before you choose an IRA provider.

What an IRA provider is for

An individual retirement account, or IRA, is a US account type for retirement saving. The provider is the company that holds the account and gives you a way to invest in it. Traditional and Roth IRAs differ in how contributions and withdrawals are taxed, and the rules, including yearly contribution limits, are set by the tax authority and can change.

Investments can fall in value as well as rise. This guide describes what to compare. It is not investment or tax advice, and it does not say which account type suits you.

What decides the value of a provider

Start with the account types the provider lists, since not every provider offers both a traditional and a Roth IRA, or other types such as a joint account. Then look at what the account can hold. Some providers offer stocks, ETFs, funds and bonds, while others focus on managed portfolios or on assets such as metals and crypto.

Charges come next. Look for account fees, management charges on managed portfolios, trading costs, charges for transfers or closing an account and any charge for extra services. Then check the platform and support, and the regulators and protection scheme the provider lists.

How the providers differ

Fidelity is a US provider founded in 1946. It lists IRA, Roth IRA and joint accounts, and its markets include stocks, ETFs, options, bonds, funds, futures and forex. It names the SEC, FINRA and SIPC among its regulators and supports customers by phone and through a community. Betterment, founded in 2008, lists IRA and Roth IRA accounts and portfolios built from ETFs, ESG funds, cash and crypto. It supports customers by phone, email, chat and a help centre.

Firstrade is a US provider founded in 1985 that lists IRA, Roth IRA and joint accounts. It runs on the web, iOS, Android and iPad, names SIPC and FINRA among its regulators and supports customers by phone and a help centre. Bitcoin IRA is a US provider founded in 2015 whose legal entity is Alternative IRA Services. It lists IRA and Roth IRA accounts with crypto and metals as markets, and apps for Apple and Android.

Self-directed or managed

With a self-directed IRA you choose the investments and place the trades. With a managed account the provider builds and rebalances a portfolio, and charges a management fee for it. Some providers offer both. Neither route is the right one by default. It depends on how much time and knowledge you want to bring, and on how you feel about the risk of loss.

If you consider an account that holds crypto or metals, check how those assets are held, who stores them and what happens if the provider fails. These assets can move sharply in price and are held under different rules from shares.

Regulators and protection

Look up the legal entity that will hold your account. A brand can use separate companies for brokerage, advice and custody, each with its own registration. Providers list regulators and a protection scheme, and these are facts about the provider, not a promise about the outcome of your investments.

A protection scheme such as SIPC is designed for certain failures at a firm. It does not cover falls in the value of your investments, so read the scheme’s own description before you rely on it.

What to check before you open an account

Check how contributions work, how a transfer or rollover from another account is handled and whether any charge applies. Look at how withdrawals are processed and at what the provider says about timing, since withdrawal rules for retirement accounts follow tax rules. Ask whether the provider can answer account questions by phone, chat or email when you need them.

Read the account agreement and the full fee schedule. Note how the provider charges for closing the account or moving it elsewhere.

How to shortlist

List the account types you want, what you want to hold and how involved you want to be, then keep the providers that offer them and name regulators you can find on a register. Compare each provider’s complete charge schedule for the way you would use the account. The IRA ranking lists the providers side by side.

See the full ranking: Top IRA providers compared →

Sources