Updated 28 September 2026 · BrokerCue Editorial Team
City Index vs Firstrade
City Index
No. 66 of 462 in stock and ETF brokers9.3Best for: A single account spanning shares, forex, CFDs, crypto and spread betting, opened with a minimum deposit of $0.

Firstrade
No. 44 of 462 in stock and ETF brokers9.5Best for: US retail investors wanting commission-free stock trading plus an IRA or joint account.
Key differences
- Firstrade scores higher overall: 9.5 against 9.3.
- Among markets, only City Index offers Forex, CFDs and Crypto.
- Among markets, only Firstrade offers Options and Funds.
Side by side
| City Index | Firstrade | |
|---|---|---|
| Cost | ||
| Minimum deposit | $0 | $0 |
| Stock trade fee | Not listed | $0at the median of 92 brokers |
| Account fee | Not listed | $0 / yearat the median of 52 brokers |
| Inactivity fee | £12 | $0 |
| Options contract fee | Not listed | $0in the lowest quarter of 38 brokers |
| Deposit and withdrawal fees | No deposit or withdrawal fees | Free for bank transfers, $25 for wire transfers |
| Trust | ||
| Regulators | Not listed | SIPC, FINRA |
| Investor protection | Not listed | SIPC up to $500,000 |
| Offer | ||
| Markets | Stocks, ETFs, Forex, CFDs, Crypto, Spread betting | Stocks, ETFs, Options, Funds |
| Platforms | Not listed | Web, iOS, Android, IPad |
| Account types | Not listed | IRA, Roth IRA, Joint |
| Trust | ||
| Retail accounts that lose money | 70%below the median of 49 brokers | Not listed |
| Other facts | ||
| Features | Not listed | Demo account, Options, Mobile app, Fractional shares |
| Pricing model | Not listed | Commission free |
| Audience | Not listed | Beginners, Experienced, Day traders |
| Company | ||
| Legal entity | Not listed | FIRSTRADE SECURITIES INC |
| Headquarters | Not listed | United States |
| Founded | Not listed | 1985 |
| Support channels | Not listed | Phone, Help centre |
Our verdict on each
City Index
City Index suits UK and European retail investors who want one account for shares, ETFs, forex, CFDs, crypto and spread betting without a deposit hurdle.
Read the full City Index reviewFirstrade
Firstrade is a US commission-free broker for retail savers who want retirement accounts and low costs in the same place.
Read the full Firstrade reviewPros and cons
City Index
Pros
- One account covers stocks, etfs and forex
- Minimum deposit rank of 1 out of 213 puts it at the top of that list
Cons
- The inactivity fee rank of 45 out of 56 sits well down the table
- Retail accounts that lose money stand at 70%, so the low entry cost does not reduce trading risk
Firstrade
Pros
- A traditional IRA, a Roth IRA and a joint account all sit in IRA, roth IRA and joint under the commission-free pricing in commission free, so retirement and shared accounts hold at the same cost.
- Fractional shares and a demo account sit in demo account, options and mobile app, which helps the beginners and day traders named in beginners, experienced and day traders start small.
- Trading runs on the platforms in Web, iOS and Android, so the same account works in a browser and on a phone or tablet.
Cons
- Live chat and email are not among the listed support channels, which pair a phone line with a help centre.
- An ISA and a SIPP are not among the listed account types (IRA, roth IRA and joint), which cover a traditional IRA, a Roth IRA and a joint account.
Who each suits
City Index
Who it suits
- Retail investors who hold shares, ETFs, forex, CFDs, crypto and spread betting in one place
- UK and European readers who want no deposit or withdrawal charges
- Traders who will use the account often and avoid the inactivity fee of £12
Who should look elsewhere
- Long term savers who may leave an account dormant and pick up the inactivity fee of £12
- Readers who want a stated regulator and protection scheme, since none is listed for this brand
- eToro buyers chasing futures, which sit in stocks, etfs and forex but not in stocks, etfs and forex
Firstrade
Who it suits
- US savers who want commission-free stock and ETF trading inside a retirement account, since the list in IRA, roth IRA and joint covers an IRA and a Roth IRA.
- Investors who trade in small amounts, because fractional shares in demo account, options and mobile app work alongside a $0 entry point.
- Day traders in US equities, named in beginners, experienced and day traders with a mobile app among the platforms in Web, iOS and Android.
Who should look elsewhere
- Traders who want forex, CFDs or crypto alongside equities: eToro lists stocks, etfs and forex and CFI lists stocks, etfs and forex, while Firstrade stays within stocks, etfs and options.
- UK and European savers who need a tax wrapper, since IRA, roth IRA and joint names no ISA or SIPP. Vantage, which sets $5 as its entry point, is worth pricing alongside.
Questions about each
City Index
What is the minimum deposit at City Index?
The minimum deposit is $0, which puts City Index at rank 1 of 213 brands on this measure. That sits below the site median of €4.64, so the account can be opened with a small starting balance.
Does City Index charge for deposits and withdrawals?
That keeps transfer charges out of the cost picture, though currency conversion on non account currency payments is not covered here.
Firstrade
What does it cost to trade stocks and options?
Stock trades cost $0 and the options contract fee is $0, so nothing is charged per trade on either side. The pricing model listed is commission free, which matches that, and the same terms apply to stocks and options contracts. A reader comparing quotes will find the same line on both markets.
Are there account or inactivity fees?
The account fee is $0 and the inactivity fee is $0, so an account can sit open and untouched without an annual charge or a dormant penalty. That suits a saver who funds a retirement account and does not trade every month, since holding a small balance costs nothing beyond the trades themselves.







